Jump to content

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'mayers vs crt'.

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • For guests...
    • Guests and new members
  • Waterways & Boating
    • New to Boating?
    • General Boating
    • Boat Building & Maintenance
    • Waterways News & Press
    • Moorings & Marinas
    • Boat Equipment
    • Living Afloat
    • Holidays Afloat
    • Cruise Diaries & Reports
    • History & Heritage
    • Stoppages
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Boat Handling
    • Vintage Engine Forum
  • General
    • Fishing, Cycling and Walking
    • For Sale & Wanted Items
  • Miscellaneous
    • Waterway & Boat Events
    • Links Directory
    • Articles, Resources and Merchandise.
  • Canal World
    • Site Announcements
    • Technical & Account Support
    • Suggestions & Feedback

Calendars

  • Events Calendar
  • Birthdays Calendar

Blogs

  • Jon's Blog
  • Pirate's Blog
  • Mick and Pauline's Blog
  • Voyages of the Odnargonauts
  • Gary Peacock's Blog
  • Raven's Problem's with The New Boat Co???
  • Blackbird
  • Honey Ryder
  • obenhack's Blog
  • biffa's Blog
  • minerva's Blog
  • minimoman's Blog
  • Paul & Kym's place
  • Graham & Jane Oliver's Website
  • Bones' Blog
  • Retirement with No Problem
  • Moore 2 Life
  • Craft A Craft
  • larner's Blog
  • Restoring Theodora
  • tafelblog
  • Misterton
  • Sunshine River Tours's Blog
  • Chris J W's Blog
  • what can you use for central heating in a narrowboat do calorifies work for that??
  • Hadar
  • Narrowboat Mr David's Blog
  • Picture This
  • Narrowboat Starcross
  • Middlewich Narrowboats' Blog
  • wiltshire_boy's Blog
  • Mark Beach's Blog
  • Photografix's Blog
  • Elysium's Blog
  • BORNJOYFUL's Blog on Tikkun
  • Silver Eel's Blog
  • andy the hammer's Blog
  • BlueStringPudding's Blog
  • Narrowboat: The Green Man
  • picture this' Blog
  • donbucks1's Blog
  • judith's Blog
  • saltysplash's Blog
  • StoneHenge's Blog
  • bassett's Blog
  • charl's Blog
  • Buffalo2's Blog
  • Shinner's Blog
  • The Beginning
  • jelunga's Blog
  • fudd's Blog
  • craig bayliss' Blog
  • tired old pirate's Blog
  • Sylver Lining' Blog
  • Gypsy Rover
  • zenonoilmills' Blog
  • Paul's Blog
  • Shamu1's Blog
  • kettleby's Blog
  • nb poppy
  • Broads cruiser liveaboard
  • dave_2A_'s Blog
  • Doug Blane's Blog
  • Pyxis' Prattlings
  • Smoke on the Water
  • Traditional narrowboat chimneys and exhausts.
  • Boaty Jo's Blog
  • Harmony
  • slick's Blog
  • zoko's Blog
  • davidjack's Blog
  • ganne's Blog
  • flek's Blog
  • Capt Flint's Blog
  • steveandangi's Blog
  • magnetman's Blog
  • Lindka's Canal Blog
  • Stu-pot's Blog
  • I used to be a plastic box...
  • CWDF Forum's Blog
  • mark collier's Blog
  • vicozzy's Blog
  • Guzziman's Blog
  • heyjude999's Blog
  • Bernard McMillan's Blog
  • richardickfuck's Blog
  • Daffodilbabe's Blog
  • davidR's Blog
  • Boat Owners
  • phonebizz's Blog
  • stagard's Blog
  • KayDee's Blog
  • Dave nbBrenda's Blog
  • Rover's Blog
  • TURNER's Blog
  • canalchris' Blog
  • tony914474's Blog
  • trebai's Blog
  • Mike Swanton's Blog
  • Jude's Blog
  • NIGELG's Blog
  • waterman's Blog
  • carole 'que sera sera''s Blog
  • long john's Blog
  • bargeeboy's Blog
  • niloc's Blog
  • artymac's Blog
  • Have you seen this boat???
  • Dekazer's Blog
  • Freedom!!!!
  • Ange's Blog
  • allybargie's Blog
  • casper ghost's Blog
  • NB The Robber Button's Blog
  • Moondaisy's Blog
  • ditchdabbler's Blog
  • undertaker's Blog
  • canaltraveller's Blog
  • waterwaysmail's Blog
  • W+T`s Cruiser
  • jeannette smith harrison's Blog
  • tom's boat's Blog
  • Martin Peers' Blog
  • timmy's Blog
  • Who Lives on the Canal
  • cratch board for sale
  • B is for Boat
  • soldthehouse's Blog
  • purdy01's Blog
  • Tooley's Boatyard's Blog
  • z1100r's Blog
  • remi's Blog
  • patty's Blog
  • Bill_Door's Blog
  • canal boat stove's Blog
  • "BaileyJades" Blog
  • My Boat Buils Blag
  • stan4's Blog
  • alan oxley's Blog
  • nb Abigail Jenna
  • DHutch's Blog
  • Diving Fun
  • Newboater1's Blog
  • In at the deep end.
  • PSSCB 2010
  • Olly`s Serenity
  • blue swan's Blog
  • josephine's Blog
  • weasel's Blog
  • old canal book man's Blog
  • BETA OIL CHANGE PUZZLE
  • competition boats' Blog
  • gypsy's Blog
  • tallpaul81's Blog
  • Life, The Universe & Everything - Grand Tour 2010
  • Sadie's Blog
  • MeganJones' Blog
  • nuts' Blog
  • simonsayssaysimon's Blog
  • NB Siskin
  • yorkshire tyke's Blog
  • Grace & Favour's Blog
  • vidang12's Blog
  • vidang12's Blog
  • sanctuary...
  • petsion's Blog
  • hilaryb's Blog
  • vontel57's Blog
  • headjog's Blog
  • valencia's Blog
  • valencia's Blog
  • valencia's Blog
  • Narrowboat "Hyskeir"
  • PatM293's Blog
  • old canal book man's Blog
  • Tom and Bex's Blog
  • old canal book man's Blog
  • Tom and Bex's Blog 2011
  • suecpage's Blog
  • myramyra's Blog
  • boatything's Blog
  • andywatson's Blog
  • stewart&jenny's Blog
  • kayontrent's Blog
  • seahawk8866's Blog
  • Uccello's Travels
  • Nickie-Noo's Blog
  • Nickie-Noo's Blog
  • Alice No1's Blog
  • Alice No1's Blog
  • Brev's Blog
  • brev's Blog
  • Dank's Blog
  • Dutch coaster barge
  • Vic the Vicar
  • awebuser's Blog
  • RoseonWildrose's Blog
  • britishgas-man's Blog
  • Keadby Lock Prop Fouling
  • lindiA's Blog
  • Nimrod VII
  • Adventures of a railway journalist
  • Paddington's Blog
  • Talk o' Devil's Blog
  • davidc's Blog
  • love2share's Blog
  • waterwheels' Blog
  • The Real Life of a Narrowboat Wife
  • Good folks on narrowboats
  • Goodie's Blog
  • redgirl's Blog
  • Jameisons Afloat
  • hardy scot's Blog
  • TARDIS' Blog
  • a.p.now's Blog
  • Adventures in Narrowboating
  • Humphrey's Blog
  • notebook's Blog
  • The Kite Experiment
  • floatingtraders' Blog
  • Boatlilfe: Living Aboard as Continuous Cruisers
  • pirate woo's Blog
  • pirate woo's Blog
  • pirate woo's Blog
  • T Fern's Blog
  • Rock Salt
  • DavidRoberts(Venetian)'s Blog
  • The Bona Boaters Blog
  • Secrets of La Licorne
  • Intermezzo
  • robby's Blog
  • Wiff' of the Woods takes to the Water
  • How much?'s Blog
  • Lancs lad's Blog
  • Lancs lad's Blog
  • tafelberg's Blog
  • Life on a wide beam
  • Erie Canal's Blog
  • boatcarecompare's Blog
  • cwwmike's Blog
  • strawberry fields' Blog
  • Maffi's Winter Trip
  • Sydknee's Blog
  • Mr Adagio's Blog
  • Mr Adagio's Blog
  • Bobbybass' Blog on diabetes type 2
  • youandi1421's Blog
  • Building a live-aboard using alternative technologies
  • bowten's Blog
  • Sofabedbarn's Blog
  • Alan&sue's Blog
  • nb. islonian
  • Boatgal's Blog
  • hughie's Blog
  • NBnutter's Blog
  • Gatesofrome's Blog
  • Tom&Lynn's Blog
  • lee b's Blog
  • sunset song
  • Narrowboating's Blog
  • bosh34's Blog
  • Adventures on Felix
  • Mario's Blog
  • Narrowboating Blog
  • carl2011's Blog
  • Ian Barber's Blog
  • bachmann's Blog
  • bachmann's Blog
  • bjc's Blog
  • NoeB4711's Blog
  • warrior princess' Blog
  • BloxwichDaryl's Blog
  • larryjc's Blog
  • Paul Mellor's Blog
  • Canal Works Nature
  • souladventurer's Blog
  • Jenkyn Knill's Blog
  • irish Waterways Blog
  • davidowens' Blog
  • wild wild wood's Blog
  • suec7566's Blog
  • Beaker's Blog
  • Cheryl's Blog
  • Total Eclipse's Blog
  • NAVI's Blog
  • Garry's Blog
  • Scribblings from the Mintball
  • Help!! Help!! Boat-life Starter
  • lfairfield's Blog
  • Sue Brown's Blog
  • Tina1's Blog
  • BlueBelle1's Blog
  • diehard's Blog
  • Les Wilkins' Blog
  • Chalky White's Blog
  • Retrolady's Blog
  • Finiancial support for famailies who live/lived on narrow boats and parents who worked at sea.
  • bobabout's Blog
  • sweatpea's Blog
  • diesel-oil's Blog
  • Mibosa's Blog
  • Gorey's Blog
  • newboata's Blog
  • julie101m's Blog
  • charlie44's Blog
  • r-harris' Blog
  • Miemie's Blog
  • Cenevieres' Blog
  • Mark Ryan's Blog
  • Nds123's Blog
  • p6rob's Blog
  • suepeters' Blog
  • Fazandgil's Blog
  • kevin222's Blog
  • Peter Selby's Blog
  • Birdswood's Blog
  • Justin1974's Blog
  • Bohemian man's Blog
  • Dream Daisy's Blog
  • Boat Haulage from Nantwich to Grangemouth
  • Tracey Barlow's Blog
  • Claire Martin's Blog
  • tier1's Blog
  • Alan&sue's Blog
  • suep's Blog
  • suep's Blog
  • suep's Blog
  • Annie Lovebug's Blog
  • Jon57's Blog
  • Bernard Jarvis' Blog
  • Bernard Jarvis' Blog
  • waterail's Blog
  • Rare's Blog
  • Angry Boater
  • debbieg's Blog
  • umpire111's Blog
  • Brick's Blog
  • Peter Turnell's Blog
  • Roman Roads' Blog
  • winding hole - aynho
  • reelax's Blog
  • Ron Cross' Blog
  • secret squirrel's Blog
  • Starling's Blog
  • Widebeam Life
  • Adventures of the Green Knight
  • Crow's Blog
  • alex19's Blog
  • Su Jonesy's Blog
  • livebaboardforever's Blog
  • Unclebuck's Blog
  • StainlessDave's Blog
  • kris daly's Blog
  • Roger Murray's Blog
  • Judgejim64's Blog
  • Su Jonesy's Blog
  • ChalkhillBlue's Blog
  • john4647's Blog
  • Brian Holt's Blog
  • hermit's Blog
  • grahamsdriving's Blog
  • spooley's Blog
  • kynance3's Blog
  • nangacoops2828's Blog
  • eaglesdad's Blog
  • Little Bo Diddley's Blog
  • Teal.366's Blog
  • Benny the Ball's Blog
  • Magneto
  • FORTUNATA's Blog
  • Roan's Blog
  • Roan's Blog
  • boswellbaby's Blog
  • debbie robbo's Blog
  • Guide to canopy fasteners
  • Jaymee's Blog
  • Saint Paul's Blog
  • Rich1983's Blog
  • kevin222's Blog
  • haza's Blog
  • Aquaman's Blog
  • Diesel Cleaning Services' Blog
  • Trillian's Blog
  • Horace42's Blog
  • kevinbsa Blog
  • RichardB's Blog
  • Blood, Sweat & Tears Blog
  • NoraChoi's Blog
  • Michael Lane's Blog
  • Michael Lane's Blog
  • RichM's Blog
  • automate's Blog
  • Plumbers London Blog
  • Local Plumber's Blog
  • janeyjane56's Blog
  • TTGE's Blog
  • Argo stolly's Blog
  • signrytin's Blog
  • Gibbo1997's Blog
  • Chris and Graham's Blog
  • Old Waterway Books
  • Chalkhill Blue 2's blog
  • David walgrove's Blog
  • JACK FELL's Blog

Find results in...

Find results that contain...


Date Created

  • Start

    End


Last Updated

  • Start

    End


Filter by number of...

Joined

  • Start

    End


Group


Skype


Website URL


Location


Interests


Occupation


Boat Name


Boat Location


Duplicate ID

Found 1 result

  1. DISTANCE NOT IMPORTANT IN CONTINUOUS CRUISING: THE COURT JUDGEMENT CRT TRIED TO HIDE December 8, 2014 nick_theboatman A recent judgement in a Section 8 case confirms that it would be unlawful for Canal & River Trust (CRT) to set a minimum distance that continuous cruisers must travel to comply with the law. The judgement in the case of CRT v Mayers states that repeated journeys between the same two places would be “bona fide navigation” if the boater had specific reason for making repeated journeys over the same stretch of canal. HHJ Halbert also stated that any requirement by CRT to use a substantial part of the canal network was not justified by Section 17(3)(c)(ii) of the British Waterways Act 1995 because the requirement to use the boat bona fide for navigation is “temporal not geographical”. In addition, Judge Halbert determined that a boat with a permanent mooring is not required ever to use its mooring. Indeed, during the course of argument CRT conceded that if Mr Mayers acquired a home mooring, he would be left undisturbed even if he did not use the mooring, provided that he did not exceed the limit of 14 days in one place. The judgement was handed down in November 2013 but CRT has not published it, unlike other judgements in Section 8 cases. Yet despite knowing about this judgement for a year, CRT is currently attempting to set a minimum distance that continuous cruisers must travel in order to comply with the law. CRT held two meetings with boating user groups on 22nd September and 3rd November 2014 in which it tried to persuade the groups to agree a minimum distance that boaters without home moorings must travel every three months and over their licence year to avoid enforcement action. CRT did not disclose this judgement at either meeting. In 2011, BW re-wrote the Mooring Guidance for Continuous Cruisers to remove the words “the law requires a genuine progressive journey (a cruise) around the network or a significant part of it” as a result of the judgement in British Waterways (BW) v Davies. The guidance was renamed Guidance for Boaters Without a Home Mooring. In 2003, British Waterways tried to introduce the Draft Moorings Code or Lock Miles Rules, which would have required continuous cruisers to travel at least 120 different lock-miles every three months without using the same stretch twice. This draconian proposal was dropped by British Waterways following the threat of legal action by a boating user group and in 2004 the Mooring Guidance for Continuous Cruisers was published instead. In spite of this judgement CRT started court action in early 2014 against a boat dweller who did not use his home mooring. It has now dropped the Section 8 claim against liveaboard Tony Dunkley. The relevant paragraphs of the CRT v Mayers judgement are reproduced below. 7.22.3 I consider the requirement imposed by CRT that a substantial part of the network is used cannot be justified by relying solely on section 17(3). That section requires “bona fide navigation throughout the period of the licence” not “bona fide navigation throughout the canal network”. The requirement is temporal not geographical. In my view it does NOT follow from: “Such journey or cruise must take place “throughout the period of the licence” that it “therefore requires progression round the network or at least a significant part of it” 7.22.4 If a person who lived permanently on his or her boat had specific reason for making repeated journeys over the same stretch of canal between two points sufficiently far apart to be regarded as different places, it would in my view be purposeful movement by water from one place to another and hence “bona fide navigation”. In the course of argument I used the example of someone who lived on his boat but was also using the vessel commercially to move coal from a mine to an iron foundry only a few miles away and then returning empty for another load. 7.22.5 To take an extreme example, in its heyday, the Mersey Ferry operated continuously to and fro over the same stretch of water which is less than a mile wide. No one would ever have accepted the suggestion that the ferry boats were not bona fide used for navigation throughout the period of their operations.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.